Can an SEO tool really tell you everything about your website’s performance?
SEO audits help identify issues, improve rankings, and enhance user experience. Many businesses rely on automated tools because they’re fast and easy. But do they really catch everything? Not always. That’s where manual SEO audits come into their own.
Automated audits are great for quick checks, but they often miss things like content quality, user experience, and deeper technical issues. A manual SEO audit, done by an expert, gives a clearer and more detailed picture.
Manual SEO audits can make a big difference for your website. Want to know how? Keep reading to find out!
Table of contents
- What is an SEO audit?
- Why do you need an SEO audit?
- Overview of SEO Audit Tools
- What is a Manual SEO Audit?
- SEO audit tools vs manual SEO audit: Which is better?
What is an SEO audit?
SEO audits are like a checkup for your website’s overall performance, identifying issues that may hurt your search rankings. It’s usually the first step we take when working with a new client and helps shape the right strategy moving forward. Depending on the need, it can cover everything from technical SEO to content performance and links, and even the legal requirements of a website (yes, there are some!).
SEO audits can also focus on specific areas that need improvement. Fixing the right issues at the right time can help you get more traffic, improve user experience and ultimately bring in more business!
Why do you need an SEO audit?
SEO audits help you identify your website’s strengths and weaknesses, as well as those of your competitors. With these insights, you can create a more effective content marketing strategy to improve your rankings.
For example:
SEO audits are like checking your wardrobe before buying new clothes. You might think you need a new shirt, but a closer look shows your shoes are falling apart. The same goes for your website—without an audit, you could focus on the wrong fixes while real issues remain. An audit helps you find and fix what really matters so your website can run better and attract more visitors.
SEO audits can be done in two ways. One way is using SEO audit tools, which scan your site automatically and highlight potential issues. The other way is a manual audit, where an expert carefully checks everything in detail to find problems that tools might miss.
Stay in the know
Keep on top of how the latest marketing, SEO, branding and design tips can be used to
grow your business – delivered straight to your inbox.
Overview of SEO audit tools
Think of SEO audit tools like a website’s personal doctor—they quickly check its health, spot issues, and suggest ways to improve performance. Pretty useful, right? And they are!
Tools like SEMrush, Ahrefs, and Screaming Frog can analyse site speed, backlinks, keyword usage, and technical errors—all in just a few minutes.
Here’s why businesses rely on SEO audit tools to streamline their success!
Why do businesses love SEO audit tools?
Let’s be honest—these tools are a lifesaver for many businesses. They take care of tedious SEO tasks in no time, making optimisation feel effortless.
- Super fast and efficient: Instead of manually checking each page, these tools scan everything in minutes.
- Can handle huge amounts of data: Whether your site has 50 pages or 50,000, audit tools process them all without breaking a sweat.
- Automates the boring stuff: Do you have any broken links, missing meta tags, or duplicate content? The tool finds them instantly, so you don’t have to.
Pretty great, right? Well… yes and no.
Even though audit tools offer multiple benefits, they can still miss some important aspects of SEO. What are they? Scroll down to see for yourself!
Where do SEO audit tools miss the mark?
1. No context, just data
SEO tools can flag low keyword density, missing meta tags, or thin content, but they can’t tell if your writing is actually useful, engaging, or answering user intent. This is because they lack the ‘context’, i.e. the understanding of your business, your audience, and your unique selling points that a human expert can provide.
For example, a blog post stuffed with keywords might pass an SEO check but fail to provide real value to readers. A human expert, however, can assess whether the content truly meets audience needs.
2. Blind to UX and design issues
A tool can check for broken links and mobile-friendliness, but it won’t notice if your site feels cluttered, navigation is confusing, or call-to-action (CTA) buttons aren’t attracting clicks.
Imagine an online store where the “Buy Now” button is too small or hidden—an SEO tool won’t flag this as an issue, but a manual review would catch it instantly.
Your website’s design directly impacts SEO, user experience, and conversions. Want to know how? Check out our blog to learn more: How Website Design Affects SEO.
3. Generic recommendations
SEO tools provide automated suggestions, but SEO isn’t a one-size-fits-all strategy. For example, a tool may recommend adding more keywords to a product page, but if that makes the text unnatural or salesy, it could hurt conversions. This is a ‘generic recommendation’ that doesn’t take into account the respective needs and characteristics of your business.
Similarly, an e-commerce site and a blog require different SEO approaches, but tools often don’t differentiate between them.
4. Too much data, not enough strategy
human analysis, it’s difficult to turn that data into action.
For example, an SEO tool might highlight a high bounce rate but won’t explain why—it could be slow load times, irrelevant content, or a misleading title. A human audit connects the dots and provides a strategic plan.
So, what’s the solution?
SEO audit tools are a great starting point, but they can’t replace real human analysis. That’s where manual SEO audits come in. An expert can go beyond the numbers, understand your audience, and create a strategy that actually works.
What is a manual SEO audit?
If SEO audit tools are like robots scanning a website for issues, then a manual SEO audit is like having an expert personally inspect every detail. Instead of just relying on automated reports, a manual audit involves a deep, hands-on analysis to understand what’s really helping or hurting your website’s performance, providing a human touch that can’t be replicated by tools.
What does a manual SEO audit cover?
1. Technical SEO (with human validation)
2. On-page SEO and content quality
3. User experience (UX) and accessibility
4. Competitor analysis & business-specific insights
Why do manual SEO audits matter?
1. Personalised recommendations
2. Deeper content and keyword analysis
3. Human interpretation of SEO guidelines
4. Spot hidden opportunities
5. Custom SEO strategy development
A manual audit isn’t just about spotting problems. It’s about creating a clear plan to help your website grow and succeed in the long run.
In the end, SEO tools are great for quick checks, but when it comes to real, lasting results, nothing beats human expertise.
SEO audit tools vs manual SEO audit: Which is better
Should you rely on automated tools or opt for a manual audit when improving your website’s SEO?
The truth is manual SEO audits take the win—but that doesn’t mean SEO tools don’t have their place.
To help you decide which approach works best for you, let’s break down the key differences between manual and automated SEO audits in a simple way.
| Aspect | Manual SEO Audit | Automated SEO Audit |
|---|---|---|
| Depth of analysis | Comprehensive and detailed | Limited to predefined parameters |
| Customisation | Highly customised to business needs | Generic recommendations |
| Speed | Time-consuming | Fast and efficient |
| Cost | Expensive | Cost-effective |
| Scalability | Limited scalability | Highly scalable |
| Human judgment | Relies on human expertise | Lacks human judgment |
| Error rate | Prone to human error | Prone to false positives/negatives |
| Ideal use case | Complex websites, competitive industries | Small to medium websites, regular monitoring |
Why do manual SEO audits come out on top?
SEO tools are fast. They can scan your website in seconds, find broken links, and flag technical errors. But they don’t think like humans. They can’t tell if your content actually makes sense to readers, if it answers their questions, or if your site feels smooth and easy to use.
That’s where manual SEO audits shine. A human expert can:
- Spot weak content that tools might miss
- Analyse if your website truly delivers a great user experience
- Craft SEO strategies that actually match your business goals
SEO isn’t just about checking boxes—it’s about creating a website that people love to visit.
But SEO tools still have their place
Manual audits take time, and no one wants to sift through thousands of pages manually. SEO tools help with:
- Speeding up technical checks
- Analysing large amounts of data
- Finding quick fixes like broken links and duplicate content
Think of SEO tools as assistants. They give you insights, but they don’t have the final say.
A mix of both can work wonders.
Instead of choosing one over the other, why not use both? Let SEO tools handle the numbers but rely on human expertise to make sense of it all. A manual audit ensures your SEO strategy isn’t just data-driven but people-driven—which is exactly what Google (and your visitors) care about.
At the end of the day, SEO isn’t just about ranking higher. It’s about growth, visibility, and creating a website that actually works. And that’s something no tool can fully understand.
If you’re an accountant looking to grow your online presence and attract more clients, let’s create an SEO strategy that works for you. Schedule a free consultation with us to learn more about the health of your website.
